CARBON SEQUESTRATION
DEBATED - 8th December 2003
Cambrensis’ Renewables
and Hydrogen Contact Group considered the current status and future
prospects for CO2 sequestrations in the
UK and elsewhere at it meeting in London on 28th November.
Dr
Jeff Chapman, Trade Partner’s UK’s
export promoter for worldwide energy gave a very lively presentation
on the prospects
for this technology and its uses and potential around the world. He
also covered the US-led Carbon Sequestration Leadership Forum and its
most recent meetings in America.
With kind permission of
the authors, the meeting also considered presentations given at the
Carbon Sequestration Leadership Forum in the USA in June
2003 by –
-
RK
Pachauri, Chairman Intergovernmental Panel on Climate Change
-
Odd Sverre Haraldsen, Deputy Director General, Ministry of Petroleum
and Energy, Norway
-
Angel
Perez-Sainz, Head of Unit, Energy Production and Distribution,
DG Research, European
Commission
William
Wilson, Director of Cambrensis and environmental lawyer gave an ‘Introduction to the Legal Issues in Geological Carbon Sequestration’.
He concluded that –
-
Legal
controls have not been designed with current technology in mind.
Environmental
protection is patchy and inconsistent, and does
not take account of the wider picture, e.g. where CO2 will
be discharged if it is not sequestered;
-
It
does not much matter to the environment whether the CO2 is discharged
from a vessel, pipeline, offshore installation or other
man-made structure – what matters is whether the
CO2 once discharged stays put, and if not what environmental
effects it might have, good
or bad;
-
The
UK’s
approach at present is cautious and timid, and it applies
the precautionary principle to CO2 sequestration without
giving equal weight to what is happening to the CO2 now;
-
The
contrast with Norway is very striking, with the Norwegian government
already pumping
1 million tonnes per year of CO2 into the
Utsira formation in the North Sea in the Sleipner field,
and planning a further 0.7 million tonnes per year in the Snohvit
development;
-
The
UK by contrast has published a report, convened a stakeholder
meeting, held some
seminars…
-
Timing
issues, with the North Sea structures approaching the end of
their useful
life, are critical;
-
Scientific
research to achieve a better assessment of the real risk and
expected environmental
outcomes is urgent and highly
important;
-
Negotiations
to make any necessary amendments to be able to introduce CO2
sequestration
if and when that proves to be scientifically
justifiable are urgent, and should be under way now.
NEXT MEETING
of Cambrensis’ Renewables and Hydrogen Contact Group:
Friday
30th January 2004 2 p.m.- 4 p.m.
Middle Temple Hall, Middle Temple Lane, London EC4
‘Renewables Targets’
Richard
Brook, Business Development Manager, NaREC will be speaking on technological aspects
of renewables and the prospects of meeting
the UK government’s renewables targets.
Melville
Haggard, Executive Director, Impax Capital Corporation will
be speaking on the economic aspects of different renewable technologies,
and their likely impact on achieving the targets.
For
enquiries about membership of Cambrensis’ Renewables and
Hydrogen Contact Group, or to request copies of presentations
given at its meetings,
please contact us